Delve into the detailed legal analysis conducted by the court in the case concerning the transfer of NRI quota seats to unreserved categories. The court’s examination of relevant statutes, precedents, and constitutional principles sheds light on the complexities of this contentious issue within the realm of education and reservation policies.
Facts
- Clause 5.5.4 of the Prospectus includes the NRI quota seats within the ‘special reservation’ category.
- Fresh applications for the NRI quota cannot be invited close to the completion of the counselling process.
- CEE transferred 47 vacant NRI seats in private medical institutions to the general state quota for the mop-up round.
- CEE can transfer unavailed NRI seats to the State merit quota under Clause 5.5.4 of the Prospectus.
- The appeal against the judgement of the High Court regarding sharing of unfilled NRI seats was dismissed by the Supreme Court.
- The vacant NRI seats were filled up in accordance with the rules stipulated in the Admission Rules 2008.
- A second round for stray vacancy allotment was conducted to fill vacant seats in self-financing colleges.
- Clause 5.5.4 of the Prospectus provides for the transfer of unavailed seats of special reservation, including PwD, to the mandatory reservation quota.
- The time for fresh registration in the NRI quota was not granted as per the provisions of the Prospectus and rules.
- 45 NRI quota seats were converted to State merit seats due to lack of options filed during counselling.
- Notification issued on 25 June 2021 for candidates to make corrections to their applications.
- Online applications for NEET-UG 2021-22 were invited from 1 June 2021 to 21 June 2021.
- A total of 358 seats in the NRI quota in unaided private medical colleges in Kerala.
- Two extensions given for submission of documents.
- Appellants are NEET-qualified candidates who applied for MBBS seats under NRI category.
- Government permitted NRI candidates to rectify attestation defects by 31 March 2022.
- Management Association requested fresh applications due to Covid-19 constraints.
- 57 seats remained vacant even after exhaustion of NRI rank list.
- Writ petition filed on 24 March 2022 seeking time for NRI quota registrations before mop-up counselling.
- Last date for application submission extended to 24 June 2021.
- Dispute on transferring NRI quota seats to unreserved category in private medical colleges in Kerala.
- No eligible NRI candidate available for vacant seats.
- Rank list of eligible NRI quota candidates exhausted after two counselling rounds by CEE.
- Appellants were not parties in High Court.
- Candidates allowed to rectify defects from 11 September 2021 to 17 September 2021.
Also Read: Balancing Power and Transparency: Electoral Bonds Struck Down, Disclosure Mandated
Arguments
- The representation of the respondent association to the CEE for inviting fresh applicants for the NRI quota was rejected.
- Vacant NRI quota seats cannot be transferred according to the State of Kerala.
- A three-Judge Bench in Modern Dental College v. State of MP ruled that vacant NRI seats in unaided institutions cannot be transferred to the State.
- The admission of unreserved category candidates to the 46 NRI seats in the mop-up and stray vacancy counselling rounds is considered contrary to law.
- The appellants did not challenge the prospectus nor the information bulletin stating that vacant NRI seats shall be transferred.
- NRI quota seats are argued not to fall within the purview of ‘special reservation’ under clause 5.5.4 of the Prospectus.
- None of the 7 appellants whose names were on the NRI list had exercised their options with respect to the 45 vacant NRI seats that were transferred.
Also Read: Recall of Resolution Plan Approval: Legal Analysis
Analysis
- None of the 7 candidates registered options for the 45 NRI seats, later converted to unreserved seats.
- Provisions in the Information Bulletin allow conversion of vacant NRI seats to unreserved during mop-up round.
- The legality of such seat conversion cannot be decided as it was not challenged.
- The reasoning of the High Court that unoccupied NRI quota seats can be transferred to state merit is deemed erroneous.
- The conversion to unreserved seats was to prevent them from remaining vacant, with higher-ranked candidates being allotted those seats.
- Clause 5.5.4 was sought only for an extension in document submission for NRI quota seats.
- Observations in Modern Dental College case were made for 2011-2012 admissions, prompting a referral to a larger Bench.
- The issue of transferring unfilled NRI seats to the State is pending before a Constitution Bench.
- Observations in PA Inamdar and TMA Pai cases should be considered along with Article 15(5) from the Constitution.
- In the academic year of 2012-13, the transfer of vacant NRI seats was also contested.
- Constitution Bench in TMA Pai Foundation held that unfilled NRI quota seats can only be filled by the management at its discretion.
- Three-judge Bench reiterated this observation in TMA Pai Foundation case.
- Imposition of reservation policy of the State on unaided private universities was held to be an encroachment on the autonomy of private professional educational institutions in Inamdar case.
- Modern Dental College and Research Centre case addressed the issue of transferring unfilled NRI seats to the State.
- Challenges were made to the constitutional validity of Madhya Pradesh Niji Byavsayik Shikshan Sanstha (Pravesh Ka Viniyaman Avam Shulk Ka Nirsharan) Adhiniyam 2007 and the rules framed under it.
- Provisions of the 2007 Act giving the State Government control over the selection process and fee fixation for medical courses were found contrary to the principles in TMA Pai Foundation and PA Inamdar cases.
- Interim order was issued for admission to medical seats in unaided colleges for the academic term of 2009-10.
- Dispute arose over unfilled NRI quota seats in RD Gardi Medical College.
- CEE rejected the representation as sufficient time and extension had been provided for document submission.
- The association only sought an extension of time for NRI quota seat candidates.
- The appellants did not claim that the rejection of the representation was done in a malicious or arbitrary manner.
Decision
- The appeals have been dismissed for the reasons provided in the judgment.
- Any pending applications have been disposed of.
Case Title: MAHA P. Vs. THE STATE OF KERALA (2022 INSC 585)
Case Number: C.A. No.-003654-003654 / 2022
