In a significant development, the Delhi High Court has ruled in favor of restoration of recognition for all courses offered by Shimla College of Education. This decision follows a detailed examination of the case concerning building safety and faculty credentials. The court’s decision will impact the future of education at the institution and ensure quality standards are maintained. Follow for more details on this groundbreaking ruling by the Delhi High Court.
Facts
- Recognition granted to the petitioner for 100 students in B.Ed. course and 100 students in D.El. Ed.
- Observation of NRC regarding Building Safety Certificate noted and discussion held
- Copy of faculty list for B.Ed. programme approved by Asst. Registrar (Acad.), H.P. University provided
- Copy of report dated 08.11.2023 of the Tehsildar stating ownership of land by Shimla College of Education submitted
- Engineer’s observation that the building visually seems safe and fit for occupancy during normal conditions (2023-28)
Analysis
- The judgment emphasizes that the application for recognition applies not only to the B.Ed. programme conducted by the petitioner but to all three programmes.
- The prayer in the appeal is considered the primary focus over the mention in the title of the appeal.
- The Appellate Committee decided to remand the matter for fresh consideration after a new inspection.
- The necessary documents were to be uploaded on the institution’s website, as evidenced by a screenshot of the website.
- Submission of land documents with Building Completion Certificate, Building Safety Certificate, and Building Plan was required.
- The appeal is deemed to extend to all three programmes until August 2023.
- Appellate Committee decision to remand the case
- Institution entitled to benefits of withdrawal
- Restriction of decision to B.Ed. Course conducted by petitioner
- The decision of the Appellate Committee must apply to all three courses where recognition was withdrawn.
- The restoration of recognition pending a fresh consideration applies to all courses conducted by the petitioner.
- The petitioner is entitled to restoration of recognition for all courses during the fresh consideration process.
Decision
- Recognition of the petitioner is restored for all three courses: B.Ed., D.El.Ed., and M.Ed.
- Restoration is subject to the outcome of a fresh inspection and consideration as directed by the Appellate Committee.
- The respondent must update the petitioner’s status on their website as a recognized institute for the mentioned courses.
- Fresh restoration orders should be issued for all three courses and the Affiliating Body must be appropriately informed.
- The respondent has a deadline of two weeks to complete the necessary steps.
Case Title: SHIMLA COLLEGE OF EDUCATION Vs. NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACHER EDUCATION & ANR. (2024:DHC:4719)
Case Number: W.P.(C)-76/2024
